How does the Beckham Law compare to similar laws in other countries?

The Beckham Law in Spain allows foreign residents to be taxed at a flat rate for income earned in the country, offering favorable tax treatment for high-income individuals.

The Beckham Law is Spain’s special expatriate tax regime designed to attract highly skilled foreign workers by offering favorable tax conditions. While other countries have similar tax regimes to attract expatriates, the Beckham Law has distinct features. Here’s how it compares to similar laws in other countries:

1. Flat Tax Rate vs. Progressive Tax Systems

  • Beckham Law (Spain): The Beckham Law offers a flat tax rate of 24% on Spanish-sourced income for expatriates, up to €600,000 per year. Income exceeding this threshold is taxed at 47%. This flat rate is significantly lower than the progressive tax rates that apply to regular residents in Spain, which can go up to 47% on income beyond certain thresholds​.

  • Portugal’s Non-Habitual Resident (NHR) Regime: Portugal offers a similar program under its NHR regime, which provides a flat 20% tax rate on certain Portuguese-sourced income for expatriates working in high-value professions. Foreign income, such as pensions and dividends, can be exempt from taxation under the NHR, depending on the source country’s tax treaty with Portugal​.

  • Italy’s Flat Tax for New Residents: Italy offers a special flat tax regime for high-net-worth individuals relocating to Italy, allowing them to pay a fixed €100,000 annual tax on foreign income, regardless of the amount earned. This contrasts with the Beckham Law, which focuses on income earned within the country​.

2. Scope of Income Taxation

  • Beckham Law (Spain): Under the Beckham Law, only Spanish-sourced income is subject to taxation, while foreign income is generally exempt. This is particularly advantageous for expatriates with substantial income sources outside of Spain.

  • United Kingdom’s Resident Non-Domiciled (RND) Status: The UK offers a favorable tax regime for non-domiciled residents, allowing them to pay tax only on UK-sourced income or foreign income remitted to the UK. This “remittance basis” can result in significant tax savings for expatriates with substantial foreign income​.

  • Netherlands’ 30% Ruling: The Netherlands provides a tax exemption for 30% of an expatriate’s gross salary, effectively reducing the taxable income. This benefit applies for up to five years and is intended to cover additional costs of relocating to the Netherlands. Unlike the Beckham Law, this ruling applies a percentage reduction rather than a flat tax rate​.

3. Duration of Tax Benefits

  • Beckham Law (Spain): The benefits under the Beckham Law are available for up to six years. After this period, expatriates revert to the standard Spanish tax regime, where they are taxed on their worldwide income at progressive rates​.

  • Portugal’s NHR Regime: The NHR regime offers tax benefits for a period of 10 years, which is longer than the Beckham Law. This extended duration makes Portugal’s regime more attractive for long-term expatriates​.

  • Italy’s Flat Tax: Italy’s flat tax regime is available for 15 years, offering a longer-term benefit than the Beckham Law. This extended duration is particularly appealing for individuals looking to establish long-term residency in Italy​.

4. Target Audience and Impact

  • Beckham Law (Spain): The Beckham Law was initially designed to attract highly skilled professionals, particularly in sports and finance. It has been successful in making Spain a destination for top talent, particularly in La Liga, Spain’s premier football league​.

  • France’s Inpatriate Regime: France offers an “inpatriate” tax regime aimed at attracting senior executives and skilled workers. This regime provides a tax exemption on 30% of the expatriate’s salary for a period of eight years, similar to the Beckham Law but with different eligibility criteria and benefits.

Summary

The Beckham Law offers a competitive flat tax rate on Spanish income, making it attractive for high earners, particularly in sectors like sports and finance. Compared to similar regimes in Portugal, Italy, the UK, and the Netherlands, the Beckham Law is relatively short in duration (six years) but effective in attracting top talent. Other countries offer longer-term benefits or different scopes of taxation, such as Portugal’s 10-year NHR regime or Italy’s flat tax on foreign income, providing expatriates with various options depending on their financial and professional needs.